« Oh You Mitt! | Main | 'Nefarious Activity' was Occurring at the Site. Why we are Losing the War in Afghanistan as Well. »

The Manichean Presidency

Firedoglake commentary:

The central purpose of the book is to examine what has happened to the United States for the last six years under the Bush presidency. That is the "Bush legacy" -- our national character and national identity have been fundamentally degraded, our moral standing and credibility in the world eroded to previously unthinkable depths, our government engaged in the very behavior which, for decades, we have collectively deplored, our trust in America's governmental and journalistic institutions reduced virtually to zero, and our country placed on a plainly unsustainable course as a result of the militarized, imperial role we are choosing to play in the world.

At the heart of this process lies a binary moralistic view of the world, one which seeks to define every conflict and political challenge, both foreign and domestic, as a battle of Good versus Evil. The crux of this mindset is the continuous identification of an Enemy, one which embodies Evil and which must be stopped, typically destroyed, at all costs. No competing considerations, no rational arguments, no counter-balancing objectives, not even constraints of reality or resources, can compete with the moral imperative of this mission. The mission of destroying Evil trumps all. . . .

This Manichean mentality not only drives George W. Bush personally, but it also consumes our political discourse almost entirely. It is this mindset, more than any other single cause, that has driven us to embrace extraordinary policies and truly radical beliefs that are as ill-considered and incoherent as they are destructive. This is the "moral reasoning" which led us to invade and indefinitely occupy Iraq, to vest previously unimaginable power in the President, to allow our country to become symbolized by orange-jumpsuit-clad, shackled and leashed detainees locked away and brutally maltreated in lawless prisons around the world, and which has brought us to the brink of still new wars in the Middle East, most alarmingly with Iran. It is this reasoning which has rendered our country virtually unrecognizable, and has placed us on a course which simply cannot be sustained.

First of all, I suppose we need to define "Manichean" for the non-Catholics out there:

An adherent of the dualistic religious system of Manes, a combination of Gnostic Christianity, Buddhism, Zoroastrianism, and various other elements, with a basic doctrine of a conflict between light and dark, matter being regarded as dark and evil.

The ultimate problem with this belief is that it denies both human nature and free will. People are not just puppets either of God or Satan (or however you define your deities). This sort of black and white think usually ends up working against people. They might think that anyone invoking the name of Jesus must be purely good and so you end up with crooks like Jim Bakker or political hacks like Pat Robertson getting rich on the charity of naive people and putting a holy glow around their own political agenda.

And on the other side, you have those who are different being tarred with the worst possible slander. If you ask a really hard core right winger what he thinks about Muslims, he won't just talk about what the person believes, he'll automatically believe that they live only to kill non-Muslims. So by that reasoning, this is a battle to the death -- there is no negotiation, no co-existence, just kill or be killed. If Iran develops a bomb, of course they'll use it immediately. If there is an Islamic neighborhood somewhere in Paris or Brussels, that means that "Eurostan" is just around the corner. It's like they're living the book of Revelation in their own minds every single day.

Of course this is insanity when it becomes the political policy of a superpower nation like the United States. When Bush told the world that they were either "with us or against us," he really believed it and really believed that even if the whole world thought he was off his rocker, God himself would intervene since he was fighting the good fight.

And if we grabbed a bad guy -- which would be defined as anyone who wasn't a True Believer -- then he was a demon-possessed brute and must be tortured to find out what evil plans they have at the moment since reason would have no effect on such a sub-human and they are ALWAYS plotting death and destruction.

And it's not just Bush's holy war. If you are an environmentalist, you are denying God's creation as well as the dominion that he gave man. You are a heathen who worships Gaea. If you believe that the poor should have enough to eat, you're a Communist and everyone knows that the commies hated Christ. If you support abortion, even at the earliest stages of pregnancy, you are a killer because God mysteriously endows humanity on the single cell at the moment of conception. They can't explain it or prove it, but they sure do believe it...

It's almost like a new Dark Ages. Reason has gone out the window and everything these folks believe is faith based. Three of the candidates running for the Republican nomination don't even believe in evolution. Denying science in favor of literal interpretation of the bible is the litmus test of the True Believer.

And yet these same folks are the ones who complain that Islam must be destroyed because it's full of discredited ideas and superstition. Go figure...

I just hope that there are still enough Americans left who maintain some shred of rationality that the next president will operate on reason rather than a twisted form of faith. Otherwise, the beliefs of the True Believers might come to pass as their hatred and ignorance drives a wedge deeper and deeper into humanity.

Note: Wizbang Blue is now closed and our authors have moved on. Paul Hooson can now be found at Wizbang Pop!. Please come see him there!

  • Currently 4.2/5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Rating: 4.2/5 (5 votes cast)

Comments (3)

Paul Hamilton:

Left the link to the original story out of this entry earlier, but it's there now...

Steve Crickmore:

Bush, I'm beginning to feel was the dimwitted maleable patsy for the neocons desire for world domination.."Iraq was to be the test case for true believers from the Heritage Foundation. and elsewhere who were more interested in trying out crackpot flat tax theories than in actually getting Iraq running." Their idea was to change reality not to study it..It has been an unbelievable waste and natural bullies like Bush and Cheney have learned precious little Christian humility, and failed to recognize anything 'demonic' in their own reckless schemes, that have wrought such disaster and unbelievable hardship.

Lee Ward:

and the fact that so many on the pious right just stood by and allowed it to happen, all the while calling those who spoke up against it "traitorous" and "terrorists", has insured that I will be speaking up and out against Republicans until the very last minute the polls are open election day November 8.

We may or may not succeed in kicking the Republicans out of power totally and completely, but if we fail it won't be for the lack of trying.


Send e-mail tips to us:

[email protected]





Add to Technorati Favorites


Publisher: Kevin Aylward

Editors: Lee Ward, Larkin, Paul S Hooson, and Steve Crickmore

All original content copyright © 2007 by Wizbang®, LLC. All rights reserved. Wizbang® is a registered service mark. Wizbang Blue™ is a trademark of Wizbang®, LLC.

Powered by Movable Type 3.35

Hosting by ServInt

Ratings on this site are powered by the Ajax Ratings Pro plugin for Movable Type.

Search on this site is powered by the FastSearch plugin for Movable Type.

Blogrolls on this site are powered by the MT-Blogroll.

Temporary site design is based on Cutline and Cutline for MT. Graphics by Apothegm Designs.